EARNING AND TRADE AND COMMERCE
(Source: Ihya-Ulum-Id-Din by Imam Ghazzali (r.a.) Revival of Religious Learnings-
English Translation by Fazlul Karim  Publisher Darul-Ishaat Karachi Pakistan)
 DATE: 450-505 (A.H.) 1058 -1111 A.D.

Earnings and Trade and Commerce

Allah made the next world the place of reward and punishments and this world the place of efforts, troubles and earnings. Earning is not the aim of human life but it is hereafter and the door to enter it. The world is the seed ground for the men:
 

Merits of earning livelihood

Allah says in Holy Quran

There is no fault in searching livelihood from your Lord. A party travel in the world to search for the grace of Allah. Spread out in the earth and seek the wealth of Allah.
 
One day, the Prophet was seated in the mosque of Medina with companions, when a stout and strong young man was going to his shop running by the mosque; The companions said: Alas for this young man! Had his body and health run in the way of Allah! The Prophet then said: Don’t say like this. If this young man runs with the object of not depending on others and refraining from begging, he is in the way of Allah. If he makes efforts for livelihood of his weak parents or weak children, he is in the way of Allah. If he tries to show his health out of pride, he is in the way of the Satan.

Allah loves one who adopts the path of labour to save himself from depending on other. Allah hates one who obtain education thinking it is a means of earning.  Allah loves the believing businessman. The best lawful earning is that which one gets by his own lawful earning. If he obeys the rules of Shariat in his business, it is the greatest lawful earnings of his own.

T he Prophet said: Take to trade and commerce, because nine-tenths of the source of earnings is in trade and commerce.

Once the Prophet Jesus asked a man: What do you do? He said: I make divine service. Jesus asked: Who gives you food? He said: My brother. The Prophet said: Your brother makes better divine service than you.

The Prophet said: I have left no such instruction which if obeyed will not bring you near paradise and keep you distant from Hell. I have left no such prohibition which, if obeyed, will not keep you distant from paradise and bring you near Hell. The trusted Spirit infused into my soul saying: No man will die till his provision does not finish even though he wishes it. So fear Allah and seek livelihood in a lawful manner. I enjoin you to earn livelihood in a just manner. Let nobody say: Give up to seek livelihood. Then he said at last: Let not the delay in earning livelihood give you encouragement to earn it illegally, because disobedience to Allah cannot bring what He has got. The markets are the repositories of food of Allah. He who comes to them gets something therefrom. If anyone of you gathers fuels with a rope and searches livelihood by bearing it upon his back, it is better than to beg of men whether they give or not. If a man opens a door of begging upon him, Allah will open for him seventy doors of begging.

Wise sayings:   The wise Luqman advised his son: O dear son, shut up poverty by lawful earnings, because he who is poor earns three habits (1)  laxity in religious actions, (2) weakness in intellect and (3) loss of manliness.  Greater fault than these three is to keep it secret from the people.

Sayyidna Omar said: Let none of  you refrain from earning livelihood and say: O Allah, give me provision. Know it for certain that the heaven will not shower rain of gold and silver. ]

Sayyidna Jaber was once sowing seeds in his field. Sayyidna Omar said to him: If you do good, you will not depend on the people. It will save your religion and you will be honoured by them.

Hazrat Ibrahim-b-Adham was asked: Who is better of the two a truthful merchant and a worshipper?   He said: A truthful merchant is dearer to me, as he is in Jihad.  The devil comes to him in the part of weight and measure and buy and sale.  He makes Jihad with him. Sayyidna Omar said: No place is dearer to me than that where  I search livelihood for my family members and where I buy and sell.

When a strong tempest arose in the sea, the passengers of a boat asked Ibrahim-b-Adham: Don't you look to this calamity?  He said: I don't consider it a calamity. Depending on men for a necessity is a calamity.

Once the Prophet asked about livelihood of beasts and birds. He said: They come out hungry in the morning and return with full belly in the evening. In other words, they come out in search of their livelihood. The companions of the Prophet used to do trade and commerce in land and sea and worked in gardens. It is sufficient to follow them.

Once  Aozayi saw the sage Ibrahim-b-Adham to bear a load of fuels on his back and said: O Abu Ishaq, why are you taking such trouble? Our brethren are sufficient for you. He said: O Abu Amer, leave me alone in this matter, as I have come to know that if a man waits in a place of disgrace in search for earning lawful livelihood, Paradise is sure for him.

The object of trade and commerce is to gain either necessary livelihood or to gain enormous wealth. The latter is the root of attachment to the world which is the basis of all sins. It is better for persons not to beg for four reasons:

These four kinds of persons remain busy in the affairs of the public or in their religious affairs. The Prophet was not commissioned to be a tradesman, rather he was directed  to glorify Allah. For this reason, when Sayyidna Abu Bakr became Caliph, other companions advised him to give up his business and  they fixed for him monthly allowance from the State Treasury. He advised his sons to return it to the Treasury after his death.

 Four things are necessary in earnings (1) Lawful earnings, (2) Justice, (3) Kindness and (4) Fear of religion.

(1) Lawful and Unlawful Earnings.

Earnings can be searched in six ways:

To know the rules of Shariat in these concerns is compulsory, as to search knowledge is compulsory for every Muslim.

It was reported that Omar used to visit the markets and instruct some inexperienced tradesmen on whipping them and say: Nobody shall carry on business in our markets who has got no knowledge of business.

(a) Bargaining in buy and sale

There are three subjects in it,

(i) Buyer and seller,

With regard to the first, no transaction is valid with a minor, insane, slave or blind man. No minor and insane man have got any sin. No transaction is valid with a slave except with the permission of his master. Transaction with a blind man is not lawful except with the consent of his representative. It is lawful to have transaction with an  unbeliever but it is unlawful to sell arms to them.

(ii) Commodities for sale.

(iii)  Contract for buy and sale

The contract for buy and sale must be expressed in clear and unambiguous terms. Intention plays an important part in it. No condition can lawfully be imposed by one party after agreement is final. Auction sale is lawful if the terms are proclaimed before hand.  Imam Shafeyi held such auction as unlawful.

(b) Trade on interest,

Transaction of Interest. Allah made interest unlawful and there is strict order of prohibition regarding it.  The question of interest arises in only two cases, in transactions of cash money, gold and silver and of food stuffs.  Interest occurs in these two cases only under two conditions,

Three things are to be observed in case of gold and silver. Food-stuffs. The food-stuffs of seller and buyer are of different kinds or of the same kinds. When food stuffs are of the same kind, it is lawful to exchange them and the rules of the same of things are applicable in this case. If a man gives a goat and takes in exchange mutton on credit or in cash, it is unlawful. To give wheat and to take in exchange bread on credit or in cash is unlawful. If milk is given to a milk trader and if in exchange clarified butter, butter or cheese is taken, it will be unlawful.

 Advance payment. Some conditions are to be observed in advance payment of money and things.

(c) Wages, salary and rental:

There are two rules (1)  wages remuneration and   (2) profit.
(1) If wages are in cash, it must be fixed like the price of a thing sold. If the remuneration is salary or rental, its kind and quantity should be fixed.  It is not lawful to let out a house on rent on condition that the tenant must construct the building or house as the expense of a house is unknown. To give skin in lieu of taking skin from the body, to give skin in lieu of carrying an animal and to give outer cover for cushing wheat are all unlawful.

(2) Profit. The object of industry in business is to gain profit.

Partnership business.
There are  three things in partnership business: (1) Principal, (2) Profit, and  (3) Kind of business.
(1) With regard to the principal in business, it will be fixed and paid in cash.
The businessman becomes the representative or agent of business who can utilise the capital according to his wish in the business.

Partnership business is of four kind. Out of them three kinds are unlawful and the fourth  is lawful.
 

Justice to be Observed in Business

 It is unlawful to give trouble to the public by unjust dealings and oppression and by deceit and fraud. There are two kinds of loss by deceit and fraud.
(1) One kind of loss for the general public and (2)  another for some special persons.

(1) The loss of the public is of many kinds. One kind of public loss arises from hoarding of food stuffs. It is done with the object of getting enhanced price of food stuffs. It is an oppression to the people in general. There is curse of Shariat on the hoarders of food stuffs.

Someone said that he commits sin of murdering all people.

Sayyidna Ali said: If a man hoards up food stuffs even for a day to gain increased price, his heart becomes hard.

The Quran says: If a man intends to transgress the limits unjustly, I will give him taste of a grievous chastisement.
This applies to hoarding up for getting more profit.

A certain pious merchant sent food stuffs on a boat in the sea to his agent at Basra with the instruction that he should sell it as soon as they reached him. When the commodities reached Basra, the merchants told him to hoard them for one week and then sell, because they would bring greater profit. His agents did accordingly and sold them after one week with increased price and informed his master. His master wrote to him: You have acted contrary to my wish. It was not my wish to make loss in religion and gain profit in commodities. I have committed sin of hoarding. Therefore, distribute all the proceeds to the poor and the destitute. In that case, I may save myself from the sin of hoarding.

It is, therefore, prohibited to hoard up food stuffs for getting greater profit, but it is connected with the kinds of food and time. It is not prohibited to hoard up such kinds of thing which are not principal food stuffs for livelihood, such as medicine, Saffron  etc. There are differences of opinion with regard to the hoarding of things which are near principal food stuffs, such as meat, fruits and such kinds of food which appease hunger and which are taken as alternatives of principal crops.

There are things which become unlawful for hoarding regard being had to the time when food stuffs are not easily available and there are needs of men for them. To make delay in selling food stuffs is harmful to the public. But when there are no such circumstances, it is lawful to make some delay as the public do not suffer by it. When there is famine, it is harmful then to hoard up even honey, clarified butter, meat and such things. So the legality and illegality of hoarding of food stuffs becomes according to the harms caused or not caused to the public.
Use of counterfeit coins. It is an oppression on the public to use counterfeit coins. The first man who uses such coin will get the sins of every person who subsequently transfers it to other persons. This is like introducing a bad custom.

A certain sage said: To transfer a counterfeit coin to another is worse than the theft of a hundred coins, as theft is confined to a sin, while the circulation of a counterfeit coin is not limited and it continues years after years unless they are destroyed.
Allah says; I shall write what they sent in advance (during their life time) and what they will send (after their death).

Allah says: Man will be informed what they sent in advance before and what they latter.

Five Rules of Counterfeit Coins
 

 It is an act of oppression if a merchant is caused loss. It is justice not to do loss to a Muslim. The general rule is: love for others what you love for yourself. This should be observed in four dealings, Allah says: There is a guard over man of what one utters.

The Prophet said: In false oath, there is much loss of commodities and there is less profit. The Prophet said: Allah will not look on three persons on the Resurrection Day a proud disobedient man, one who deals harshly after charity and one who sells things by oath.

Not Conceal Defects of Commodities

One who conceals defects is an oppressor, a deceit and a fraud. Deceit is unlawful.  Once the prophet saw a man selling food stuffs and it pleased him. The Prophet then entered his hand unto the interior of the food stuffs and found moisture in them. He asked him: Why are there wet things in them? The man replied: Rain melted them. He said: Has not the rain fallen on the top of the crops? The Prophet then said: He who defrauds us is not of us. The Prophet took allegiance of Islam from Jarir and when he was about to go, he took promise from his that he should do good to the Muslim. Thereafter, whenever Jarir was present at the time of transaction of a thing, he disclosed the defects of it and gave him option to purchase. Some one said to him: You will not get profit by it. He said: I made promise to the Prophet that I shall seek good of every Muslim.
The Prophet said: It is unlawful to sell a thing without disclosing its defects and one who knows it will commit sin if he does not give precaution to him.

A man had a cow. He milked his cow everyday and sold milk after mixing water therein. One day there was flood which drowned the cow. One of his sons said to him: The waters which you mixed with milk gathered together and washed away the cow by a strong current.

It becomes easy to seek good of the people if one knows that the profit in the next world is better than the wealth and treasures of the world and that these will end with the end of life, but his sins and virtues will remain. So how can a man take to evil things instead of good ones? Don't conceal in weights and measures. Take recourse to just  balance and weight. The way to be rescued from this is the following. Give more when you measure out to others and take less when you take by measure from the people. When the Prophet purchased something, he used to tell the seller: Weigh according to the amount of price and give measure a little more.

Hazrat Solaiman said to his son: O dear son, sin enters between two transaction just as seeds enter into mills.

Tell truth in selling commodities and do not conceal anything. The Prophet said: Don't meet the riders who bring commodities. The owner of the commodities has got option to break an agreement after they are brought in the market with those who meet them in advance.

To Do Good in Mutual Transactions

Allah ordered us to adopt good and just dealings and to do good to the people.

Allah’s mercy is near those who do good. Doing good means an act which does benefit to another. Though it is not compulsory, it brings rewards and ranks. The rank of doing good can be obtained in one of the following six actions.

(a) Not to make much profit. Sale is for profit in a business and there is no profit unless a thing is charged more than the price by which it is bought. To take less profit is ‘Ihsan’, doing good but to take greater profit is not unlawful. Once a man bought a bundle of cloth from the salesman of Eunus-b-Obaid for 400 dirhams which was to be sold for 200 dirhams to the buyer. He said to his salesman: Why have you not loved for another which you love for yourself? Return half. Sayyidna Ali used to roam in the bazaar of Kufa with a stick and say: O merchants, take your dues and return the dues of others. Don't refuse little profit or else you will be deprived of greater profit. Sayyidna Abdur Rahman-b-Auf was asked: What is the reason of your success? He said: Three things

 (b) To suffer loss. If a buyer buys from a poor man, there is no harm to buy at a higher price to show good to him and to enter into this prayer of the Prophet: May Allah like a person who makes his buy easy and purchase easy? When he purchases a thing from a rich man, he may search for additional profit. Sayyidna Omar did not do any deceit and nobody could ever deceive him.

(c) To show good and to treat well at the time of acceptance of price and realization of dues. It is expressed in three ways

The Prophet said: May Allah show mercy on easy purchase, easy sale, easy payment of price and easy payment of debt. Consider the prayer of the Prophet as valuable. Forgive and you will be forgiven. He said: If a man grants time to a needy man to repay debt or remits it, Allah will make his account easy. In another narration: Allah will give him shade on the day when there will be no shade except that of the Throne.

The Prophet mentioned about such a person who oppressed, his soul very much and was engaged in sins. When he will be presented on the Judgement Day, it will be found that he has got no good deeds. He will be asked: Did you no do any good deed?  He will say: No, but I advanced loan to the people. I used to say to my children: Grant time to the solvent and remit the poor. Allah then will say: I am more fit in this matter than you. Then Allah will forgive him.

The Prophet said: I saw it written on the door of Paradise: One act of charity will bring ten rewards and one act of loan will bring eighteen rewards. It is said here by way of explanation that charity may not always reach the truly poor, but none but the needy bears the disgrace of loan. If a man sells something to a man and does not then realize its price and does not demand it, it is considered as a loan.

When Hasan Basari sold his donkey  for four hundred dirhams, the purchaser said to him: Reduce it by one, hundred dirhams. He reduced it so. He again said: Do good to me. He said: I remit you another one hundred dirhams. Then he accepted two hundred dirhams and said: In this way, good is done to a person.

There is in Hadis: Accept your dues with pardon, whether it is paid up in full or not, then Allah will make your account easy.

(d) To do good at the time of payment of debt. To pay debt in a good manner is ‘Ihsan’ or doing good to another. Clear the debt before demand. Going to the creditor personally and not to wait for its demand is considered doing good.
 

(e) To accept return of a thing sold if the buyer thinks that he has suffered loss, as nobody except a repentant or suffering man intends to return a purchased thing. None should remain satisfied with causing loss to his brother Muslim. (f) To sell things to the needy on credit and not to demand from them when they are in want and do not become solvent. The religious men of yore kept account books. In those books, they wrote the names of unknown poor customers. They were forgive if they could not pay their dues.

Trade and commerce are the places for trial of religious persons. For this reason, it has been said that when the neighbours of a person praise him, when the companions of a man in journey praise him and when the fellow tradesmen in the market praise him, don't complain against his good character.
Once a witness went to depose before Sayyidna Omar. He said to him: Bring one to me who knows you. When he brought a person to him, the man began to praise his character. Sayyidna Omar asked him: Is he your closest neighbour? He said: No. Sayyidna Omar asked him: Were you his companion in a journey? He said: No. Sayyidna Omar then asked him: Did you carry on business with him? He said: No. Sayyidna Omar said:  So, you don't know him. He then said to the man: Go, take one who knows you.
 

Not to be Forgetful of Religion and the Next World in Business

 Nobody should forget his religion and the next world his destination during the course of his trade and commerce and earning livelihood. If he forgets it, he will then be ruined and he will then be one of those who sells his next world in lieu of this world, but the wise man is he who protects his capital. His real capital is his religion and matters relating to the next world.

A certain sage said: The best commodity in this world to a wise man is what is absolutely necessary for him in this world. The necessary things in this world are praise-worthy in the next world.

Hazrat Muaz-b-Jabal gave his death instruction by saying: What has been decreed for you from the fortunes of this world will surely come to you, but it is more necessary on your part to look to your fortunes of the next world. So begin your actions for the fortunes of the next world.

In other words, don't forget the portion of your fate in the next world from your portion of fate of this world, as the world is a seed ground for the next world.
 

Seven Things Make the Religion of a Business Man Perfect
 

Intend to be upon the duties of Farze Kafayah like trade, commerce, industry thinking that, if the various kinds of trade and industry are given up, it will be difficult for the people to manage their livelihood and the majority of the people would be destroyed. One people are responsible for one kind of work. If all remain busy in only one kind of work, all other work would remain idle and hence the people would be destroyed. With this object, There is in hadis: The business of cloth is the best of all your trades and the work of sewing is the best of all industries.

There is in another hadis: Had the inmates of Paradise had trades, they would have the trade of cloth. Had the inmates of Hell had any trade, they would have carried on business of exchange of coins.

There are four works in which there is fear of lessening the intellect- (1) weaving of cloth,  (2) sale of cotton,  (3) weaving of thread and (4)  Teaching, because in these works mostly women, boy and men of little intellect are engaged.  As intellect increased in association of intellectuals, so also it lessens in association of less intellectual men.

Let not the worldly markets be blocks of the next worldly markets which are mosques.

So you should work for the next world in the early part of the day till market time, remain attached to the mosque and remain busy in divine service after the division of times. The earlier sages fixed the early and last part of the day for the next world and the middle part for this world.

There is in hadis: If the angels who write records of deeds write therein Allah’s Zikr and good deeds in the early part and the last part of the day, Allah forgives sins between these two times.

There is in hadis: The angels of day and night meet with one another at the time of morning and Asar prayers. Allah then says: In what condition have you found My servants? They say: We have seen them praying and came from them in their praying state.

Allah says: I bear witness in your presence that I have forgiven them.

Be attached to the Zikr of Allah in addition to the above duties in the markets. Allah’s remembrance in the markets is better. The Prophet said: One remembering Allah among the heedless is like a warrior behind a fleeing enemy or like a living man among the dead. In another narration: Or like a living trees amidst dried trees.

The Prophet said: If a man says after entering the market the following; There is no deity but Allah, the Single, there is no partner for Him, His is the kingdom and for, Him is all praise, He give life and takes life, He is eternal and will not die, in His hands, there is good and He is powerful over all things’ Allah reward him with thousands of merits.

Sayyidna Omar said: O Allah, I seek refuge to Thee from infidelity and all the sins committed in the markets. O Allah, I seek refuge to Thee from the oath of the sinners and the wailings of the losers. The Prophet said: Fear Allah wherever you are. Markets, mosques and houses are all the same for those who fear Allah. They live for Allah and die for Allah and Allah is the corner stone of their life.

A certain sage said: He who loves the next world loves a true life. He who loves this world remains thirsty.

Don't be too greedy in markets and in businesses. There is in hadis: Don't travel in the sea except for Pilgrimage, Umrah and Jihad. The Prophet said: The worst of places is the market. The sage Hammad used to carry on wool rugs. When he got profit of nearly six annans (1/16) , he used to close his business. Once Ibrahim-b-Adham said to a person who was going to his business of pottery: You are seeking livelihood but death seeks you.  Keep away from doubtful things even after giving up unlawful things. Leave the places of the earnings of doubt and restrain yourself from eating doubtful things.

Once a man brought milk to the Prophet who asked him: Where from has this milk come to you? He said: we have got it from goats. The Prophet asked: Where from have you got goats? He said: From such and such a place. Then he drank it and said: We are a people of Prophets. We have been forbidden to eat except good things and to do except good deeds. The believers have been ordered to do the things which the Prophet have been ordered to do.
 

The Prophet asked the source of a thing and the source of its source and not beyond that. The Prophet did not enquire about everything. Don't do business with one who has got connection with oppression, breach of trust, theft and interest.

The Prophet said: He who prays for long life on an oppressor, loves to he disobedient to Allah in His world. He said: When any transgressor is praised, Allah becomes displeased. He also said: He who honours a transgressor, helps the destruction of Islam.

Adjust accounts of your business with everybody. Accounts will be taken of you on the Resurrection Day of your business with everybody.  A wise man said: I saw a merchant in dream and asked him: What treatment has Allah metted out to you? He said: Fifty thousand account books have been opened before me. I asked: Are all these records of sin? He said: You will find one record for each person you have dealt with in the world. All have been recorded in these account books. 

Contact us: